Breville Barista Express vs Pro: Which Should You Buy? (2025 Comparison)
After pulling over 500 shots between these two machines over the past month, I discovered something surprising: the more expensive option isn't always the better choice. Both the Barista Express and Barista Pro sit in that sweet spot of home espresso machines sophisticated enough to pull café-quality shots, yet approachable enough that you won't need a barista certification to operate them.
Here's what makes this comparison interesting: Breville continues to sell both models side by side, and they're both consistently ranked among Amazon's best-selling espresso machines. The Pro costs about 30% more than the Express, but that doesn't automatically make it 30% better. In fact, after extensive testing, I'd argue that most home baristas would be happier saving their money, but there are some specific situations where the Pro absolutely shines.
Let me walk you through everything that actually matters when choosing between these two machines, from the morning rush reality to the weekend coffee ritual experience.
Quick Verdict
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Barista Express | Barista Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Price Range | $500-700 | $700-900 |
| Heat-up Time | 45 seconds | 3 seconds |
| Grinder Settings | 18 settings | 30 settings |
| Display Type | Analog pressure gauge | LCD digital screen |
| Steam Wand | Single hole (traditional) | 4-hole (commercial style) |
| Water Heating | ThermoCoil | ThermoJet |
| Pre-infusion | Manual only | Programmable |
| Water Tank | 67 oz | 67 oz |
| Rating | 4.5/5 ⭐ | 4.3/5 ⭐ |
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
The 7 Key Differences That Actually Matter
Before diving deep into each feature, let's address the elephant in the room: these machines share about 80% of their DNA. They use the same 15-bar Italian pump, identical portafilter size, same water tank capacity, and most importantly, the same extraction system that actually makes your espresso.
The differences lie in the experience of using them, not necessarily in the quality of coffee they produce. Here's what actually separates them:
Key Differences
- Heating System - Pro heats in 3 seconds vs Express's 45 seconds
- Interface - Digital LCD vs analog pressure gauge
- Grinder Settings - 30 vs 18 settings
- Steam Wand - 4-hole vs single hole
Additional Differences
- Pre-infusion Control - Programmable vs manual only
- Workflow Speed - Pro is about 40% faster for multiple drinks
- Learning Curve - Pro is easier for beginners, Express teaches you more
The Pro isn't meant to replace the Express. Instead, it's positioned as a faster, more convenient alternative for those willing to pay a premium for speed and digital controls.
Heating System: The Game-Changing Difference
This is where the Barista Pro truly sets itself apart. The ThermoJet heating system is genuinely revolutionary for home espresso machines. Three seconds from cold to ready is no marketing gimmick-I've timed it repeatedly, and it consistently delivers.
The Barista Express ThermoCoil Experience
The Barista Express uses Breville's ThermoCoil system, which heats water by passing it through a heated metal coil. In practice, this means:
- • 45-second initial heat-up (though I recommend waiting 2-3 minutes for true temperature stability)
- • 30-45 second recovery time between brewing and steaming
- • Temperature surfing becomes part of your routine
- • Making multiple milk drinks requires patience
Morning Test Result: Making two cappuccinos took about 6 minutes from cold start with the Express.
The Barista Pro ThermoJet Advantage
The Pro's ThermoJet represents a completely different approach:
- • 3-second heat-up that's actually ready at 3 seconds
- • Near-instant transition between brewing and steaming
- • No temperature surfing needed
- • Consistent temperature shot after shot
Morning Test Result: The same two cappuccinos took just 3.5 minutes from cold start.
But here's the counterpoint: if you're someone who enjoys the ritual of making coffee, that extra time with the Express isn't necessarily a negative. I actually found myself appreciating the forced slowdown on weekend mornings. The Express makes you more deliberate, more involved in the process.
Grinder Deep Dive: When More Settings Matter
Both machines use conical burr grinders that are identical in mechanism-the only difference is the adjustment range. But this difference can matter more than you might think.
The Express: 18 Settings of Simplicity
The Barista Express grinder is the definition of "good enough for most people." With 18 settings, I had no trouble dialing in:
- • Medium roasts (settings 8-12)
- • Dark roasts (settings 5-8)
- • Espresso blends (settings 6-10)
- • Most single origins (settings 8-14)
Where it struggled: Very light roasts, especially Nordic-style roasts, sometimes needed a fineness between available settings.
The Pro: 30 Settings for Precision
The Barista Pro's 30 settings aren't just marketing-they make a real difference for coffee enthusiasts who buy various beans. The extra resolution helped me dial in:
- • Light roasts that the Express couldn't quite nail
- • Competition-style espresso requiring precise adjustment
- • Experimental processing methods
- • Day-to-day adjustments as beans age
The verdict: If you stick to one or two types of coffee, the Express is perfectly adequate. If you experiment with different beans, the Pro's precision is genuinely useful.
User Interface: Digital Convenience vs Analog Feedback
The Express: Old School Charm
The analog pressure gauge on the Express isn't just aesthetic-it's a learning tool. Watching the needle climb teaches you about:
- • Pre-infusion pressure
- • Extraction pressure
- • When something's wrong (channeling shows as pressure fluctuations)
- • The relationship between grind size and pressure
Programming is straightforward but manual. You'll press and hold buttons, count seconds, and repeat until you get it right.
The Pro: Modern Simplicity
The LCD interface makes everything more intuitive:
- • Shot timer runs automatically
- • Temperature displayed in real-time
- • Menu navigation is logical
- • Programming takes seconds, not minutes
- • Grind time adjustment is easier to fine-tune
For beginners, the Pro is undeniably easier. But the Express actually teaches you more about espresso.
Steam Wand Performance: Speed vs Control
The steam wand difference is more significant than the spec sheet suggests.
Express: The Traditional Approach
The single-hole steam wand requires technique:
- • 45-60 seconds to steam 6oz of milk
- • Positioning matters enormously
- • Creates a satisfying vortex when done right
- • Better for latte art (more control over texture)
- • Steep learning curve (expect a week of practice)
I spilled milk everywhere my first few days with the Express. But once I got the hang of it, I could create microfoam that rivaled my local café.
Pro: Commercial-Style Efficiency
The 4-hole steam wand is friendlier:
- • 25-30 seconds for 6oz of milk
- • More forgiving positioning
- • Consistent results with less skill
- • Good enough for basic latte art
- • Minimal learning curve
The Pro's wand is what you want if you're making multiple drinks or if others in your household will use the machine.
Real-World Testing: 30 Days, 500+ Shots
I tested both machines extensively, using the same medium roast coffee (a Colombian from a local roaster) to ensure fair comparison.
Morning Routine Test Results
Barista Express:
- • Average time for 2 cappuccinos: 6 minutes
- • Consistency: Excellent once warmed up
- • User experience: Meditative but sometimes frustrating when rushed
- • Guest usability: 3/5 (pressure gauge confused visitors)
Barista Pro:
- • Average time for 2 cappuccinos: 3.5 minutes
- • Consistency: Excellent from first shot
- • User experience: Efficient and stress-free
- • Guest usability: 5/5 (anyone could figure it out)
Taste Test Results
The Surprise:
Using the same beans, same dose (18g), same yield (36g), and same timing (27 seconds), I couldn't consistently tell the difference in blind taste tests.
Both machines pulled shots with:
- • Rich crema
- • Balanced extraction
- • Proper temperature (200°F ± 2°F)
- • Identical flavor profiles
The Pro's shots were ready faster, but they weren't better. This makes sense-both use the same 15-bar pump and extraction system.
Temperature Stability Test
I pulled 5 consecutive shots on each machine:
Express:
First shot ran 2°F cooler than the rest. Shots 2-5 were consistent within 1°F.
Pro:
All 5 shots within 1°F of each other. The ThermoJet system is remarkably stable.
Build Quality and Long-Term Ownership
After researching owner forums and Reddit communities, plus examining both machines internally, here's what to expect:
What's Identical:
- • 15-bar Ulka pump (Italian-made, same model)
- • Brass boiler components
- • Metal internal frame
- • 54mm commercial-style portafilter
- • Stainless steel exterior panels
Common Issues (Both Models):
- • Grinder may need adjustment after 2-3 years
- • Solenoid valve replacement around year 4-5
- • Regular descaling essential (every 2-3 months)
- • Shower screen needs monthly cleaning
Reliability Verdict:
Neither has a clear advantage. Both machines share most internal components, and long-term reliability appears identical based on user reports. The 2-year warranty covers both equally.
Who Should Buy the Barista Express?
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
The Express remains the better choice if you:
- •Want maximum value - Save the price difference for a quality grinder upgrade later
- •Enjoy the process - The ritual of temperature surfing and manual control adds to the experience
- •Are learning espresso - The pressure gauge teaches you more about extraction
- •Make 1-2 drinks at a time - The slower heat-up doesn't matter for single servings
- •Prefer analog controls - Sometimes simpler is better
- •Have a flexible morning routine - Those extra 3 minutes won't break your schedule
- •Plan to upgrade eventually - The Express is a perfect stepping stone machine
The Express forces you to slow down and pay attention. For many coffee lovers, that's a feature, not a bug.
Who Should Buy the Barista Pro?
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
The Pro justifies its premium if you:
- •Value every second - Those 3-second heat-ups add up over months and years
- •Make multiple milk drinks daily - The workflow efficiency is dramatic with 3+ drinks
- •Have multiple users - The digital interface is more intuitive for households
- •Switch between different coffees - Those 30 grind settings provide needed flexibility
- •Prefer modern interfaces - The LCD provides better feedback for programming
- •Want maximum convenience - It's the closest thing to automated in a semi-automatic
- •Entertain frequently - Making drinks for guests is significantly faster
The Pro is about removing friction from your coffee routine. If that's worth the premium to you, you won't regret it.
The Hidden Third Option: Barista Express Impress
Before you decide, consider the Barista Express Impress (typically priced between these two). It adds:
- " Assisted tamping system (perfect dose every time)
- " Express heating system (same 45 seconds)
- " Express grinder (18 settings)
- " Intelligent dosing that learns your preferences
For many people, this might be the actual sweet spot-addressing the Express's main weakness (consistency for beginners) without the Pro's price premium.
Shopping Tips and Best Deals
Based on price tracking over the past year:
Best Sale Timing:
- • Black Friday: typically 20-25% off
- • Prime Day: 15-20% off
- • Mother's Day: seasonal promotions
Money-Saving Tips:
- • Refurbished options: Save 30-40% with 1-year warranty
- • Bundle deals: Williams-Sonoma and Sur La Table occasionally bundle with accessories
- • Price matching: Many retailers will match Amazon's price
Never pay full retail for either machine-they go on sale every 6-8 weeks.
My Verdict: The Express Wins (Usually)
After a month with both machines, I'm keeping the Barista Express. Here's why:
The coffee quality is identical. That's the bottom line that matters most. The Pro makes the process faster and easier, but it doesn't make better espresso. For most people, the Express offers 95% of the experience at 70% of the price.
That saved money? Put it toward a better grinder in a year or two. A Baratza Sette 270 or Eureka Mignon will improve your coffee more than the jump from Express to Pro.
However, the Pro absolutely makes sense if speed is critical to your lifestyle. If you're making multiple milk drinks every morning before work, those saved minutes add up to hours over a month. The Pro turns coffee-making from a ritual into a routine-whether that's good or bad depends entirely on your perspective.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Barista Express and Pro?
The main difference is the heating system. The Barista Pro uses ThermoJet technology for 3-second heat-up, while the Express uses ThermoCoil requiring 45 seconds. The Pro also has 30 grind settings vs 18, an LCD display vs analog gauge, and a 4-hole steam wand vs single hole.
Is the Barista Pro worth the extra money?
For most people, no. The Barista Express offers identical coffee quality at a lower price. The Pro is worth it only if you value the 3-second heat-up time, make multiple milk drinks daily, or need the extra grind settings for various coffee types.
Which machine makes better espresso?
Neither - they produce identical espresso quality. Both machines use the same 15-bar pump, extraction system, and 54mm portafilter. The Pro is faster and more convenient, but the actual coffee quality is the same.
Which Breville machine is better for beginners?
The Barista Pro is easier for absolute beginners due to its digital interface and more forgiving 4-hole steam wand. However, the Barista Express's pressure gauge teaches you more about espresso extraction, making it better for those who want to learn.
Can I use the same accessories for both machines?
Yes, both machines use the same 54mm portafilter size, so all baskets, tampers, distribution tools, and most accessories are compatible between them.
How long does each machine take to make a cappuccino?
From cold start: Barista Express takes about 3 minutes for one cappuccino (45s heat-up + brewing + steaming). Barista Pro takes about 1.5 minutes (3s heat-up + brewing + steaming). The Pro saves even more time when making multiple drinks.
Which machine is better for light roast coffee?
The Barista Pro with its 30 grind settings offers better precision for dialing in light roasts. The Express's 18 settings can work but sometimes you'll wish for a setting between the available options.
Final Thoughts
The Breville Barista Express vs Pro debate ultimately comes down to one question: is convenience worth the premium? The Pro is undeniably the more refined machine-faster, easier, more flexible. But the Express remains one of the best values in home espresso, delivering identical coffee quality with just a bit more hands-on involvement.
For most people, the Express is the smarter buy. Take the money you save and invest in great coffee beans, a proper scale, or even a coffee course. Any of those will improve your daily cup more than the Pro's conveniences.
But if those morning minutes matter, if multiple users need simplicity, or if digital controls just make you happy, the Pro is an excellent machine that you won't regret buying.
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Express
All-in-one espresso machine with built-in grinder and pressure gauge for café-quality coffee at home.
- Built-in grinder with 18 settings
- Analog pressure gauge for learning
- 45-second ThermoCoil heat-up
- Best value in its class
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
*Price and availability may vary. Click to see the latest offers.
Breville Barista Pro
Professional espresso in seconds with 3-second heat-up, LCD display, 30 grind settings, and fast milk steaming.
- 3-second ThermoJet heat-up
- 30 grind settings for precision
- LCD display with shot timer
- 4-hole steam wand for speed
Related Articles
Top 10 Best Coffee Machines for 2025→
A comprehensive guide to the best coffee machines for every budget and need. Compare features, prices, and find the perfect machine for your home.
Automatic vs Manual Coffee Machines: The Ultimate Guide→
Compare automatic and manual coffee machines to find which type suits your needs. Expert insights on features, prices, and user experience.
Best Espresso Machines 2025: A Barista's Guide→
Expert reviews of the top espresso machines for home use. Compare features, prices and get professional buying tips.