Nespresso Vertuo Plus vs Next: Complete Review & Comparison (2025)

I need to address this upfront because it's the deciding factor: the Vertuo Next has serious, well-documented reliability issues that Nespresso hasn't adequately resolved.

During my three-month testing period, my Vertuo Next developed the infamous leaking problem twice. Water would pool under the machine after brewing, sometimes dripping from the bottom, other times leaking from the capsule chamber. I'm not alone. Thousands of users report similar issues, many within the first 6-12 months of ownership.

The manual lever brew head on the Next appears to be the culprit. Unlike the motorized system in the Plus that applies consistent pressure and creates a reliable seal, the Next's lever mechanism often fails to create a proper seal with the capsule. This leads to leaking, weak coffee, and eventually complete failure.

My Vertuo Plus, tested simultaneously for the same duration, experienced zero leaking issues. The motorized brew head closed with reassuring consistency every single time. This reliability difference alone justifies the higher price.

When both machines work properly, they produce nearly identical coffee. Both use Centrifusion technology that spins capsules at up to 7,000 RPM while injecting water, creating authentic crema and full-bodied coffee without pressure-based extraction like traditional espresso machines.

I conducted blind taste tests with the same capsules brewed on both machines. In 15 tests across different coffee varieties, I couldn't consistently identify which machine brewed which cup. The coffee tasted identical: rich, smooth, with natural crema on top.

However, consistency tells a different story. The Vertuo Plus delivered the exact same cup size and strength every single time. The Next occasionally produced varying volumes, sometimes delivering 6.5oz when set for 7.7oz coffee, or creating weaker brews as the brew head mechanism aged.

Brewing speed is identical: approximately 60 seconds from button press to finished cup, including heat-up time if the machine was recently used. Both machines use barcode reading to automatically adjust brewing parameters, so there's no manual adjustment needed.

Pick up both machines and the quality difference is immediately apparent. The Vertuo Plus feels substantial, with metal construction around the brew head and a solid, stable base. The Next feels lighter, flimsier, like a budget appliance despite Nespresso's eco-friendly recycled plastic marketing.

The Plus's motorized brew head is a marvel of engineering. Push the lever, and a motor smoothly closes the chamber with consistent force every time. You hear a satisfying mechanical hum as it seals. The Next's manual lever requires you to pull it down yourself, and the force needed varies depending on capsule type. Sometimes it feels sticky, other times too loose.

Aesthetically, both machines look sleek and modern. The Next comes in more color options (black, white, cherry red, ice white) and has a slightly more rounded, contemporary design. The Plus offers classic colors (black, chrome, red, titan) with a more angular, premium appearance. Both fit nicely on standard counters.

Counter space is similar despite marketing claims. The Next saves about half an inch in depth, negligible in real-world use. The Plus's larger footprint provides better stability, reducing vibration during the spin cycle.

This difference annoyed me more than expected during daily use. The Vertuo Plus's 60oz water tank holds enough for 8-10 cups depending on size selections. I refill it every 3-4 days with my typical usage (2-3 cups daily).

The Next's 37oz tank barely holds enough for 4-5 cups. I found myself refilling it almost daily, and if guests came over, I'd refill mid-session. This seemingly minor convenience factor became a daily frustration.

Both tanks detach easily for filling and cleaning. The Plus's tank feels more substantial with thicker plastic and a more secure attachment. The Next's tank occasionally wobbled in its housing, though it never fell out during testing.

Water level windows are clearer on the Plus, making it easier to see when refilling is needed. The Next's translucent tank requires closer inspection to judge water level accurately.

The Vertuo Next's exclusive feature is Bluetooth connectivity with the Nespresso app. After testing it extensively, I can confidently say: you don't need it, and it doesn't add meaningful value.

The app lets you start brewing from your phone (why?), tracks descaling schedules (your machine already does this), provides capsule recommendations (marketing), and offers firmware updates (occasionally useful). In three months, I used the app maybe five times total, and four of those were for testing purposes.

The app requires you to stand near the machine anyway due to Bluetooth's limited range, negating any convenience of remote brewing. Starting a brew from the machine itself takes one button press, faster than opening an app. The capsule recommendations felt more like advertising than useful suggestions.

Firmware updates potentially improve performance, but the Plus has worked flawlessly for years without app updates. The Next's updates haven't fixed its fundamental reliability problems, suggesting software can't solve hardware issues.

Both machines follow the same basic workflow: lift lever, insert capsule, close lever, press button, wait 60 seconds. The process is identical in theory, but different in practice due to the brew head mechanisms.

With the Plus, the motorized head closes smoothly and consistently. You hear a reassuring mechanical sound as it seals, and you know it's ready. Press the button, and brewing starts immediately without hesitation.

The Next's manual lever sometimes requires surprising force to close, other times it drops with minimal resistance. This inconsistency meant I never knew if I'd achieved a proper seal until brewing started. Several times, the machine flashed error lights requiring me to reopen and reseal the capsule.

Capsule removal is easier on the Plus. The motorized head automatically ejects used capsules into the container. The Next's lever sometimes left capsules stuck in the chamber, requiring manual removal with potential for hot water drips.

Heat-up time from cold is identical at about 25-30 seconds. Both machines enter standby mode after 9 minutes, requiring a brief reheat for the next cup. Energy consumption appears similar based on my usage patterns.

Daily maintenance is minimal for both machines. Empty the used capsule container when full (10 capsules for Plus, 6 for Next), wipe down the drip tray, and that's it. Takes 30 seconds.

Descaling is required every 300 capsules or when the machine indicates. The process is identical: fill tank with descaling solution, run cleaning cycle (takes 15-20 minutes), rinse thoroughly. Both machines guide you through this with LED light sequences. For detailed maintenance procedures, see our complete cleaning guide.

The Plus's larger components make cleaning slightly easier. The drip tray holds more liquid before needing emptying, and the capsule container's larger capacity means less frequent attention. These small conveniences add up over time.

Water tank cleaning should happen monthly. Both tanks detach easily and are dishwasher safe (top rack). I hand-wash mine with mild soap and warm water, takes two minutes.

Long-term maintenance differs significantly. The Plus typically runs problem-free for years with just descaling. The Next often requires troubleshooting, customer service calls, and potential replacement within 2-3 years even with perfect maintenance.

The Next costs $20-30 less upfront. That sounds like savings until you factor in lifespan and reliability.

If the Plus lasts 6 years (conservative estimate) at $180, your cost is $30 per year. If the Next lasts 2 years (common based on user reports) at $150, your cost is $75 per year. You'll need to buy 3 Next machines to match one Plus's lifespan, spending $450 vs $180.

Beyond replacement costs, there's frustration value. Dealing with leaks, inconsistent coffee, customer service calls, and potential without-machine periods while waiting for replacements. These hidden costs never appear on price tags but significantly impact ownership experience.

Capsule costs are identical since both machines use the same Vertuo pods. Nespresso capsules run $1.00-1.40 each depending on variety and purchase quantity. Neither machine offers third-party capsule compatibility due to the barcode system and proprietary design. For more on pod systems, check our Nespresso vs Keurig comparison.

Nespresso heavily markets the Next as their "most sustainable" machine, made from 54% recycled plastic. Sounds impressive until you consider that a machine lasting 2-3 years creates more waste than one lasting 6-7 years, regardless of material composition.

A durable machine is inherently more sustainable than a recyclable one that breaks prematurely. The Plus's longer lifespan means less manufacturing, shipping, packaging, and landfill waste over time. True sustainability comes from longevity, not marketing claims.

Both machines use aluminum capsules that Nespresso recycles through their collection program. Capsule sustainability is identical regardless of which machine you choose. The machine itself represents the sustainability difference.

After three months of intensive testing, hundreds of cups, and dealing with the Next's reliability issues firsthand, my recommendation is clear: buy the Vertuo Plus.

The Plus costs slightly more upfront but saves significantly over time through reliability and longevity. Its motorized brew head, larger water tank, and better construction make it the obvious choice for anyone who values consistent performance and peace of mind.

The Next's Bluetooth feature doesn't compensate for its fundamental reliability problems. The compact design saves minimal space. The recycled plastic construction feels cheap compared to the Plus's solid build. The smaller water tank becomes a daily annoyance.

Nespresso positioned the Next as the newer, better model. In reality, it's a cost-cutting exercise that sacrifices reliability for marginal savings. The Plus represents better value, better experience, and better long-term satisfaction.

If you're shopping for a Vertuo machine, save yourself future frustration and potential replacement costs. Spend the extra $20-30 on the Plus. Your morning coffee routine will thank you for years to come. For other great coffee machine options, check our comprehensive buying guides.